Hensley
Field - Mechanical/Electrical System
by
Michael Kawecki
This is the fourth of an open ended series of articles
detailing the design and construction experiences of the
Hensley Field Operations Center, a facility currently
seeking LEED certification.
In a previous
article, I discussed
the aesthetic reasoning of the raised floor at Hensley
Field. But, the true capabilities of this system only become
apparent when the mechanical and electrical systems
underneath it are designed efficiently.
CHURN
- it’s a word that every facility manager fears. Churn is
the never ending modification of administrative workstations
and cubicles. Down-sizing, up-sizing, re-org’s, new
technology – these all require modification of the modular
furniture. More importantly, the location of the electrical
and sometime mechanical systems also has to be modified.
Industry average is that a workspace will require
modification every two years. Believe me – I’ve lived
this nightmare - I work in a building with 1100 other
occupants. Even in times of economic depression, people are
relocating.
So,
let’s start with the electrical/data distribution. Data is
the backbone of our industry. 30 years ago, it was uncommon
to need a phone at every desk. Now, it’s the exact
opposite. And with more and more devices requiring network
capabilities, data use will continue to grow. To accommodate
this, we started with a centrally located data distribution
area. We physically located this room as close as possible
to the raised floor area to minimize cable length. This data
room is also quite large – it is not a converted janitor
closet! The data racks in this room lead to a central
raceway, which runs through the wall and under the floor.
This raceway runs through the center as the space, and acts
as a spine from which data can be distributed throughout the
space. Electrical is routed in the same method.
From
the raceway, data and electrical branch off to the raised
floor boxes. These boxes sit flush in the floor, and feed
the individual cubicle locations. Normally, this is where
you see the most change, where a box has to move a couple
feet in any direction. You can accommodate this by using
8’ whips on the boxes themselves, and laying out the boxes
on 10’-12’ centers. The whips allow you to easily
relocate a box one or two tiles away without having to
re-work electrical conduit.
We
made a special point to select raised floor boxes that have
quick-connects on the backs of them. This allows a
non-electrician to safely disconnect/reconnect the
electrical when the box needs to be relocated. This also
allows you to only remove the floor tiles where needed,
instead of every tile between those points.
Air
distribution follows a similar principle. Once again, the
mechanical rooms are located as close as possible to the
area, in order to minimize duct runs. There is a short
length of duct running from the air handler overhead into a
chase that then feeds down to the floor. From here, air is
dispersed into the under-floor area, which acts as a large
plenum. This plenum is pressurized and air tight, which
turns it into a large continuous air duct. From here, a VAV
box/grill can be located at any point for air diffusion.
There
are several other benefits that go with under-floor air
distribution. First, the air can be discharged at a higher
temperature while keeping the same cooling parameters. With
a diffuser in the ceiling, cool air passes through a large
volume of hot air before it gets to the user. This layer of
hot air is a result of both hot air from the space rising
and being re-circulated through the returns and also from
the heat generated from the lighting fixtures. The end
result is that when the cool air reaches the user, it has
already been warmed by several degrees.
Now,
flip the system. By discharging cool air at the floor level,
you eliminate the need to compensate for the cooling that is
lost when discharging from the ceiling. Less cooling means
less tons of AC required, which results in smaller (and less
expensive) HVAC systems. A nice side effect of this type of
system is that indoor air quality is improved, as
contaminants in the air are lifted straight up and into the
returns – the conditioned air does not mix with the
unconditioned air as it is discharged.
With
both air diffusers and raised floor boxes being able to
change at will, this space has a high degree of flexibility.
At the same time, the future cost of reconfigurations is
reduced. No longer is an electrician required for a simple
relocation of a floor box, nor is a mechanic needed to
re-route duct runs for a simple relocation of an air
diffuser. As the furniture changes, all the support systems
can change with it.