Click here to Return to USGBC North Texas Resources

Photovoltaics - What's the hold-up? 
by Randall Daniel

Technology that has the ability to transform the sun, the very reason for air conditioning, into the source that actually powers the unit has just been discovered by NASA scientists.  Well, the previous sentence might have been groundbreaking news in 1954 when this technology was first developed, but it might as well be on the front page today.  Photovoltaic (PV) cells utilize this exact technology and have been doing it for over five decades now.  It may seem hard to imagine that this technology could have existed for 50+ years and somehow managed not to take the market by store, but there have been a few things holding the revolution up.

The Photovoltaic Cell

The PV cell is an remarkable thing, transforming free and prevalent sunlight into electricity in a virtually pollution-free process.  UV light, composed of photons strikes one of a pair of oppositely charged plates creating a voltage difference and resulting in current flow.  This direct current can then be inverted to alternating current and used to power anything from your home to your hybrid vehicle.  Incredibly, the entire process consumes zero fossil fuels and results in no pollutants.  It is estimated that for the average American home, a 4-5 kWh photovoltaic system installation will eliminate some 35 lbs of harmful pollutants ( NOX and SO4) from the environment annually, and an additional 5,000 lbs of CO2 that would be produced by fossil fuel production methods.

So what has been the hold-up?  The energy source is free and renewable, and with the guarantee of such an enormous positive environmental impact, the switch to PV technology from fossil fuels would seem obvious.  Well, the answer to this question is basically cost.  Sure, you have to consider the enormous environmental cost that our society will have to pay years from now, but in the “real world”, focuses tend to be much more short-term - like within our own lifetimes.  While PV systems might be great for the environment and the future of our offspring, right now they cost more money, and we don’t like to spend more if we don’t have to.

So, exactly how much would a PV system cost, say, for my house?  Good question.  A typical PV panel system sized for the average home runs around $25,000.  (This estimate includes the panels, power inverter, and required wiring.)  For the average homeowner, this up-front installation cost is a hard swallow especially when considering the average fossil fuel based electricity rate is only $.10 kWh.   Even though a PV system can significantly reduce, if not eliminate monthly electricity bills, payback of the initial installation cost can take 25 to 30 years.  To cover the installation bill, the average homeowner could use a little help.

Making it Feasible

The good news is that the cost to manufacture PV panels continues to drop as the demand for them increases.  A general observation is that for every doubling of production volume, the cost is reduced by about 20%, and with fossil fuel energy costs rising around 3-4% annually, the point where these two methods meet is continually drawing closer. 

Additionally, governments are starting to realize the value and importance of this technology and have created several programs to encourage their installation.  On the federal level, the Bush Administration put the Energy Policy Act of 2005 into effect which offers a substantial incentive to the homeowner who installs a PV system.  The government will pay up to 30% of installation costs in the form of a tax exemption with a maximum cap of $2,000.  In addition to this federal program, some states are also offering tax exemptions and rebates.  In California , for example, the CA Solar Initiative provides $2.80 for each watt of an installed PV system.  In Texas , the state is offering several tax exemptions for the installment of PV or other solar systems, and leading the incentives in Texas , Austin Energy offers its customers $4.50 per watt of installed PV, up to %80 of installations costs with a $12,000 cap.  It is hopeful that success from these programs will encourage similar efforts nationwide.

Though PV systems are currently more expensive and will likely take several more years to gain a higher portion of the market, exponential improvements in PV technology and the introduction of government incentive programs are helping to make the switch from fossil fuels a reality.  If the environmental incentive wasn’t enough, maybe the financial will be.    

Cost estimates were calculated on BP Solar’s website at www.bp.com. More information on incentive programs can be found on www.dsireusa.org.  


Randall Daniel is a student at the University of Texas at Arlington, and wrote this article as part of a course curriculum focusing on sustainability. All comments are the sole responsibility of the author.

This article was originally posted 9/12/06.